
Enjoy fast, free delivery, exclusive deals, and award-winning movies & TV shows with Prime
Try Prime
and start saving today with fast, free delivery
Amazon Prime includes:
Fast, FREE Delivery is available to Prime members. To join, select "Try Amazon Prime and start saving today with Fast, FREE Delivery" below the Add to Cart button.
Amazon Prime members enjoy:- Cardmembers earn 5% Back at Amazon.com with a Prime Credit Card.
- Unlimited Free Two-Day Delivery
- Streaming of thousands of movies and TV shows with limited ads on Prime Video.
- A Kindle book to borrow for free each month - with no due dates
- Listen to over 2 million songs and hundreds of playlists
- Unlimited photo storage with anywhere access
Important: Your credit card will NOT be charged when you start your free trial or if you cancel during the trial period. If you're happy with Amazon Prime, do nothing. At the end of the free trial, your membership will automatically upgrade to a monthly membership.
Buy new:
$17.00$17.00
Ships from: Amazon.com Sold by: Amazon.com
Save with Used - Very Good
$6.39$6.39
$3.99 delivery April 18 - 21
Ships from: HPB-Emerald Sold by: HPB-Emerald

Download the free Kindle app and start reading Kindle books instantly on your smartphone, tablet, or computer - no Kindle device required.
Read instantly on your browser with Kindle for Web.
Using your mobile phone camera - scan the code below and download the Kindle app.
Why Kill the Innocent (Sebastian St. Cyr Mystery) Paperback – February 26, 2019
Purchase options and add-ons
London, 1814. As a cruel winter holds the city in its icy grip, the bloody body of a beautiful young musician is found half-buried in a snowdrift. Jane Ambrose's ties to Princess Charlotte, the only child of the Prince Regent and heir presumptive to the throne, panic the palace, which moves quickly to shut down any investigation into the death of the talented pianist. But Sebastian St. Cyr, Viscount Devlin, and his wife, Hero, refuse to allow Jane's murderer to escape justice.
Untangling the secrets of Jane's world leads Sebastian into a maze of dangerous treachery where each player has his or her own unsavory agenda and no one can be trusted. As the Thames freezes over and the people of London pour onto the ice for a Frost Fair, Sebastian and Hero find their investigation circling back to the palace and building to a chilling crescendo of deceit and death . . .
- Print length352 pages
- LanguageEnglish
- PublisherBerkley
- Publication dateFebruary 26, 2019
- Dimensions5.5 x 0.85 x 8.2 inches
- ISBN-100399585648
- ISBN-13978-0399585647
The chilling story of the abduction of two teenagers, their escape, and the dark secrets that, years later, bring them back to the scene of the crime. | Learn more
Frequently bought together

Customers who viewed this item also viewed
Editorial Reviews
Review
“The best St. Cyr yet.”—Booklist
“The mystery highlights the circumscribed course of women’s lives of the Regency era while exposing the rot that underlies the period’s glitter…. Highly recommended for lovers of historical thrillers.”—Library Journal, starred review
Praise for When Falcons Fall
“Harris’ talent for character development, polished prose, and accurate, Regency-era details makes this eleventh or any of the previous 10 an easy starting point for newcomers to the Sebastian St. Cyr series...Psychologically atmospheric like Imogen Robertson’s Westerman and Crowther mysteries, with the skewering social wit of Anne Perry's Charlotte and Thomas Pitt novels, this is historical mystery at its best.”—Booklist (starred review)
“An engrossing tangled mystery and astonishing tale about a tragic search for identity. An excellent choice for St. Cyr fans and readers of historical mysteries.”—Library Journal
“Strong...[an] intricate murder puzzle.”—Publishers Weekly
Praise for the Sebastian St. Cyr Mystery Series
“This riveting historical tale of tragedy and triumph, with its sly nods to Jane Austen and her characters, will enthrall you.”—Sabrina Jeffries, New York Times bestselling author
“Sebastian St. Cyr is everything you could want in a Regency-era nobleman-turned–death investigator: uncannily clever, unwaveringly reserved, and irresistibly sexy. The entire series is simply elegant.”—Lisa Gardner, #1 New York Times bestselling author
“Thoroughly enjoyable . . . Moody and atmospheric, exposing the dark underside of Regency London.”—Deanna Raybourn, New York Times bestselling author
About the Author
Excerpt. © Reprinted by permission. All rights reserved.
Clerkenwell, London: Thursday, 27 January 1814
A howling wind flung icy snow crystals into Hero Devlin's face, stinging her cold cheeks and stealing her breath. She kept her head bowed, her fists clenched in the fine cloth of her merino carriage gown as she struggled to drag its sodden weight through the knee-deep drifts clogging the ancient winding lane. A footman with a lantern staggered ahead of her to light the darkness, for Clerkenwell was a wretched, dangerous area on the outskirts of the City, and night had fallen long ago.
She was here, alone except for the footman and a petite French midwife who floundered through the snow in her wake, because of an article she was writing on the hardships faced by the families of men snatched off the streets by the Royal Navy's infamous press gangs. The midwife, Alexi Sauvage, had offered to introduce Hero to the desperate eight-months-pregnant wife of a recently impressed cooper. No one had expected the woman to go into labor just as a fierce snowstorm swept in to render the narrow lanes of the district impassable to a gentlewoman's carriage. Thanks to their presence, mother and child both survived the long, hard birth. But the snow just kept getting deeper.
"Do you see it yet?" Alexi called, peering through the whirl of white toward where Hero's carriage awaited them at the base of Shepherds' Lane.
Hero brought up a cold-numbed hand to shield her eyes. "It should be j-"
She broke off as her foot caught on something half-buried in the snow and she pitched forward to land in a deep drift on quickly outflung hands. She started to push up again, then froze as she realized she was staring at the tousled dark hair of a body that lay facedown beside her.
The footman swung about in alarm, the light from his lantern swaying wildly. "My lady!"
"Mon Dieu," whispered Alexi, coming to crouch next to her. "It's a woman. Help me turn her, quickly."
Together they heaved the stiffening woman onto her back. The winter had been so wretchedly cold, with endless weeks of freezing temperatures and soaring food and coal prices, that more and more of the city's poor were being found dead in the streets. But this was no ragged pauper woman. Her fine black pelisse was lined with fur, and the dusky curls framing her pale face were fashionably cut. Hero stared into those open sightless eyes and had no need to see the bloody gash on the side of the woman's head to know that she was dead.
"She must have slipped and hit something," said Hero.
"I don't think so." Alexi Sauvage studied the ugly wound with professional interest. As a female, she could be licensed in England to practice only as a midwife. But Alexi had trained as a physician in Italy, where such things were allowed. "She couldn't have died here. A wound like this bleeds profusely-look at all the blood in her hair and on her pelisse. Yet there's hardly any blood in the snow around her." With tender hands, she brushed away the rapidly falling flakes that half obscured the dead woman's face. "I wonder who she is."
Hero watched the snow fall away from those still features and felt her chest give an odd lurch. "I know her. She's a musician named Jane Ambrose. She teaches piano to"-she paused as Alexi swung her head to stare at her-"to Princess Charlotte. The Regent's daughter."
Chapter 2
S ebastian St. Cyr, Viscount Devlin, stood at the river steps below Westminster Bridge, his worried gaze on the turgid ice-filled expanse of the Thames before him.
Never in anyone's memory had London seen a winter such as this. Beginning in December and lasting for more than a week, a great killing fog had smothered the city with a darkness so heavy it could be felt. After that came days of endless snow that buried the entire Kingdom beneath vast drifts said in some places to run as much as twenty-three feet deep. And then, yesterday, a brief, sudden thaw sent massive blocks of ice from up the Thames spinning downriver to be carried back and forth by the tide, catching in eddies and against the arches of the bridges, where they crashed into one another with a series of echoing booms that reminded Sebastian of artillery fire. Now, with this evening's plunging temperatures and new snowfall, the city had turned into a strange black-and-white world of bleak windblown drifts cut by a ribbon of darkly dangerous ice-filled waters. And still the snow fell thick and fast around him.
He was aware of a strange silence that seemed to press down on the city, unnatural enough to be troubling. Twenty years of war combined with falling wages, soaring prices, and widespread starvation had already brought England to her knees. There was a very real worry that this vicious, killing winter might be more than the country could-or would-bear.
He glanced back at the ancient stone walls of the Houses of Parliament, which rose just beyond the bridge. They seemed so strong and invincibly enduring. Yet he knew they were not.
"Gov'nor." A familiar shrill cockney voice cut through the icy silence. "Gov'nor!"
Sebastian turned to see his sharp-faced young groom, or tiger, slip and almost fall as he took the icy footpath curling down from the bridge. "Tom? What the devil are you doing here?"
"I like t' never found ye, yer honor," said Tom, almost falling again as he skidded to a halt. "A message jist come to Brook Street from 'er ladyship."
"Yes, I heard she's been delayed in Clerkenwell."
"Aye, but this is a second message, yer honor. She's at the Queen's 'Ead near the Green, and she says you'll be wantin' t' come right away. Somebody close to Princess Charlotte's been murdered, and 'er ladyship done tripped over the body jist alyin' there in the street!"
o
He found Hero beside a roaring fire in the private parlor of a ramshackle old inn at the base of ShepherdsÕ Lane. She stood lost in thought, her hands held out to the blaze. Her wet, rich dark hair lay plastered against her face; the skirts of the elegant black gown she wore in mourning for her dead mother hung limp and sodden.
"Devlin. Thank heavens," she said, turning as he entered.
"I'm sorry it took so long for your message to find me." She was one of the strongest people he knew, determinedly rational and fiercely brave. But as she came into his arms and he held her close, he felt a faint shudder rack her tall Junoesque frame. "Are you all right?"
"Yes." She drew back to give him a lopsided smile, as if vaguely embarrassed by that brief display of vulnerability. "Although more shaken than I'd care to admit."
"Anyone would be shaken."
"Not Alexi. She's gone off to treat the cook's frostbite."
Sebastian grunted. He wasn't sure anything could shock that enigmatic fiery-haired Frenchwoman. But all he said was "Tell me what happened."
He drew her back to the fire's warmth while she provided him with a crisp, calm summary. "A couple of the parish constables are guarding the body," she said. "But I made certain they sent word directly to Sir Henry at Bow Street rather than to the public office here at Hatton Garden."
"That was wise," said Sebastian. Violent deaths connected in any way with the royal family had a tendency to present the officials involved with a Faustian dilemma. And the magistrates of Hatton Garden had in the past proven themselves to be far from reliable. "Does anyone else know yet?"
"Not to my knowledge."
Sebastian nodded, his gaze meeting hers. There was no need to give voice to what both were thinking. "Good."
o
Sir Henry Lovejoy arrived in Clerkenwell not long after Sebastian.
The Bow Street magistrate was a small man, barely five feet tall, with stern religious views, a serious demeanor, and unshakable integrity. There'd been a time not so long ago when Sebastian had been a fugitive on the run for murder and Sir Henry the magistrate tasked with tracking him down. But in the years since then an unusual friendship had developed between the Earl's son and the dour middle-aged magistrate. As different as the two men were, they shared a fierce dedication to the pursuit of justice.
Huddled now in a heavy greatcoat with a scarf covering his lower face, Sir Henry stood outside the Queen's Head in quiet consultation with his constables while Sebastian handed Hero up into her carriage. Sebastian was watching the coachman pull away to carefully guide his team down the snowy street when Sir Henry came up beside him.
"Her ladyship is certain of the victim's identity?" said the magistrate, his eyes narrowing as the carriage's rear wheels slid sideways on the icy cobbles.
Sebastian nodded. "I'm afraid so."
"Not a good situation."
"No," agreed Sebastian.
The carriage swung around a distant corner, and the two men turned to wade through the deep drifts clogging Shepherds' Lane. The snow still fell thick and fast around them.
Two parish constables stood guard over a dark, silent form rapidly disappearing beneath the falling snow. The men had been stomping their feet and swinging their arms in an effort to stay warm, but at the Bow Street magistrate's approach, both went rigid.
"At ease, men," said Sir Henry.
"Aye, yer honor," said one of the constables, although he still didn't move.
Crouching down beside Jane Ambrose's body, Sebastian yanked off his glove and used his bare hand to brush gently at the snow that had already re-covered the dead woman's lifeless skin and dark blue lips. She'd been a poignantly attractive woman, he thought, his hand curling into a fist as he rested his forearm on his bent knee; she was probably somewhere in her early thirties, with thick dark hair, wide cheekbones, and a heart-shaped face.
The side of her head was a pulpy mess.
Lovejoy thrust his hands deep into the pockets of his greatcoat and looked away. "Did you know her, as well?"
Sebastian pulled on his glove again, his gaze returning to that still, pale face. "Only by reputation." She'd been born Jane Somerset, the daughter of the organist at Westminster Abbey. As child prodigies, she and her twin, James, had given numerous musical performances to great acclaim. But modesty required females of her class to retire from public view once they reached marriageable age. And so, while her brother James Somerset had gone on to be acknowledged as a promising young composer and one of the greatest pianists of their age, Jane had ceased to perform, married a successful dramatist named Edward Ambrose, and confined herself to such socially acceptable "feminine" pursuits as writing glees and ballads and teaching piano to the children of the wealthy. Premier amongst those students was Princess Charlotte, ebullient young daughter of the Regent and heiress presumptive to the throne behind her father.
Sebastian found himself considering Jane Ambrose's ties to the House of Hanover as he studied the pink-tinged snow around the dead woman's head. Alexi Sauvage was right: If Jane Ambrose had been killed here in Shepherds' Lane, the snow would have been drenched crimson with her blood. It was not.
"I wonder why she was left here, of all places," he said aloud.
Lovejoy hunched his shoulders against an icy gust. "Unfortunately, the wind and snow have covered any tracks her killer might have left. I suppose it's possible she was attacked somewhere near here by footpads who were then interrupted in the process of dragging the body to a less public locale."
Sebastian touched the bloodstained fur-trimmed collar of Jane Ambrose's pelisse where a gold locket still hung around the dead woman's neck. "No footpad would leave that."
Lovejoy cast a quick glance around, then crouched on the far side of the body and pitched his voice low enough to be inaudible to the constables holding back the crowds that were beginning to gather despite the freezing temperature and wind-driven snow. "And yet I fear the palace is likely to insist on saying some such thing is what happened. If we're to get a postmortem, we'd best move quickly."
Sebastian met the magistrate's gaze and nodded.
Pushing to his feet, Lovejoy sent one of his men running to the nearest deadhouse for a shell that could be used to transport the body to the surgery of Paul Gibson, an anatomist known for his ability to read the evidence left by violent death. It was when they were lifting what was left of Jane Ambrose onto the shell that Sebastian noticed the dead woman's hands, which until then had lain hidden beneath the folds of her pelisse.
They were bare.
"She's not wearing gloves," said Sebastian. "Or a hat, for that matter."
Lovejoy came to stand beside him. "How very odd." Even in the best of weather, no gentlewoman would think of appearing in public without a hat and gloves. And in this weather, it would be madness. "I'll set the lads to beating the snowdrifts to look for them. Perhaps they're lying somewhere hereabouts."
"Perhaps," said Sebastian. "But it would still be odd."
Chapter 3
W hile a solemn-faced Lovejoy set off to personally notify Edward Ambrose of his wife's death, Sebastian spent the better part of the next hour scouting the surrounding area and knocking on the doors of the ancient dilapidated houses that lined the crooked lane. He was hoping to find someone who'd seen or at least heard something. But the bitter cold and heavy snowfall had long ago driven the area's residents to their firesides; no one would admit to knowing anything.
Giving up, he stood for a moment and watched Lovejoy's constables, their lanterns shuttered against the driving snow as they continued to flounder about in the deep drifts looking for Jane Ambrose's missing hat and gloves or anything else that might help explain what had happened to her. The snow muffled their movements the same way it silenced the usual racket of the vast, freezing city around them. And it struck Sebastian that, so intense was the unnatural hush, they might have been in a snowy forest glen surrounded only by the unseen creatures of the night.
Readjusting his hat against the snow, he shook off the peculiar thought and turned his steps toward the Tower Hill surgery of a certain one-legged, opium-eating Irishman.
o
SebastianÕs friendship with the Irish surgeon Paul Gibson stretched back nearly ten years, to a time when both men wore the KingÕs colors and fought the KingÕs wars from Italy and the West Indies to the mountains of Portugal. Then a French cannonball shattered GibsonÕs lower left leg, leaving him racked with phantom pains and struggling with a dangerous opium addiction. That was when he had come here, to London, to teach anatomy at hospitals such as St. ThomasÕs and St. BartholomewÕs and to open a small surgery in the shadow of the Tower.
Product details
- Publisher : Berkley; Reprint edition (February 26, 2019)
- Language : English
- Paperback : 352 pages
- ISBN-10 : 0399585648
- ISBN-13 : 978-0399585647
- Item Weight : 10.4 ounces
- Dimensions : 5.5 x 0.85 x 8.2 inches
- Best Sellers Rank: #656,684 in Books (See Top 100 in Books)
- #5,393 in Science Fiction Crime & Mystery
- #7,077 in Historical Mystery
- #13,383 in Amateur Sleuths
- Customer Reviews:
About the author

C. S. Harris, aka Candice Proctor, is the USA TODAY bestselling author of the Sebastian St. Cyr mystery series, the C. S. Graham contemporary thriller series, seven historical romances,, and the standalone Civil War historical GOOD TIME COMING. An Air Force brat who grew up exploring castles in Spain and fishing in the mountains of Oregon and Idaho, Candy later worked as an archaeologist and earned a PhD in European history. A former academic who has lived all over the world, she now makes her home in New Orleans with her husband, former intelligence officer Steven Harris. Visit her website at www.csharris.net.
Customer reviews
Customer Reviews, including Product Star Ratings help customers to learn more about the product and decide whether it is the right product for them.
To calculate the overall star rating and percentage breakdown by star, we don’t use a simple average. Instead, our system considers things like how recent a review is and if the reviewer bought the item on Amazon. It also analyzed reviews to verify trustworthiness.
Learn more how customers reviews work on AmazonCustomers say
Customers thoroughly enjoy this book series, praising its historical mysteries that explore palace intrigue and unexplained murders, along with its rich characters and detailed research. The writing quality receives positive feedback for its entertainment value, and customers appreciate the romance elements. The pacing receives mixed reactions, with several customers finding it boring.
AI-generated from the text of customer reviews
Select to learn more
Customers find the book compelling and thoroughly enjoyable, with one customer noting it's the best written installment in the series.
"...and Hero work to uncover the truth, and all that delicious family and palace intrigue...." Read more
"Another compelling, Regency detective story in the Sebastian St. Cyr series that kept me anxious to the very end...." Read more
"Excellent book. Well written. Historically accurate, which added to the engagement of the book. Good mystery. Kept you guessing until the end." Read more
"An incomparable and mesmerizing character building was absolutely one of the many reasons this mystery series has become my obsession...." Read more
Customers enjoy the mystery content of the book, particularly its focus on unexplained murders and palace intrigue, with detailed and accurate historical elements.
"...There was a tight mystery plot, lots of twists as Sebastian and Hero work to uncover the truth, and all that delicious family and palace intrigue...." Read more
"Another compelling, Regency detective story in the Sebastian St. Cyr series that kept me anxious to the very end...." Read more
"Excellent book. Well written. Historically accurate, which added to the engagement of the book. Good mystery. Kept you guessing until the end." Read more
"...The frozen Thames of 1814 made for a cool historical major event! Loved how it played an important and amazing part to the mystery!..." Read more
Customers appreciate the character development in the book, describing them as rich and likable, with one customer noting the effective dialogue between characters.
"...I think those who enjoy historical fiction that provides well-drawn characters, authentic historical elements, complex character and action-driven..." Read more
"An incomparable and mesmerizing character building was absolutely one of the many reasons this mystery series has become my obsession...." Read more
"...I like that Hero is back to investigating enthusiastically and this book has a lot more of her in it...." Read more
"...What makes these books so interesting, are the real people who so much research has brought them very much to life!..." Read more
Customers appreciate the depth of the book, noting its obvious detailed research and fabulous descriptions, with one customer highlighting how the topic is supported by extensive research.
"...They are a sexy, intelligent, witty couple! Why doesn't BBC pick this up, make a series out of it?..." Read more
"...Strengths: this book had fabulous descriptions of the last Frost Fair held on the Thames, and they were magical and breathtaking...." Read more
"...I truly enjoy the research that goes into each of Harris' novels...." Read more
"...They are believable because of the obvious detailed research undertaken. The characters are well developed and enjoyable. #..." Read more
Customers praise the writing quality of the book, describing it as wonderful and a pure literary pleasure, with one customer noting the lovely British accents.
"...Beyond the main pair of the story, the author doesn't chintz on several other recurring minor characters who make up Sebastian's circle with their..." Read more
"Excellent book. Well written. Historically accurate, which added to the engagement of the book. Good mystery. Kept you guessing until the end." Read more
"...They are a sexy, intelligent, witty couple! Why doesn't BBC pick this up, make a series out of it?..." Read more
"...I am never disappointed. The writing is excellent, the history is detailed and accurate, and the mystery most always confounds me...." Read more
Customers enjoy the romance in the book, with one review highlighting the caring relationship and another noting the real emotion.
"...I love seeing them share intimacy and private moments as a couple and as parents to their young son...." Read more
"...I like that she and Devlin have settled into a loving, caring relationship and enjoy the many glimpses of them with Simon...." Read more
"...started off on a shaky premise, has really evolved to one of real love and trust over the course of the books...." Read more
"...While there were aspects that were sad, this one was not as heartbreaking or horrifying as the previous book in the series, for which I am grateful...." Read more
Customers have mixed opinions about the pacing of the book, with some finding it boring, while one customer describes it as beautifully crafted.
"...They are a sexy, intelligent, witty couple! Why doesn't BBC pick this up, make a series out of it?..." Read more
"...It was too sad, too pointless. It shouldn't have turned out that way...." Read more
"...I really love her character and in this installment, she was back in good form...." Read more
"...The mystery kept me guessing 'til the end. Sebastian and Hero are richly drawn and human characters that you really care about...." Read more
Top reviews from the United States
There was a problem filtering reviews. Please reload the page.
- Reviewed in the United States on April 8, 2018Royal intrigue, a gifted female musician, the Frost Fair, Rothschild gold, and a cunning mystery draw Sebastian and Hero into a dangerous, wintry hunt.
The story opens with Hero stumbling over the nearly frozen body of Jane Ambrose, piano teacher to Princess Charlotte. The palace covers up the death, but Hero and Sebastian take up the investigation. They soon work out that any number of people, mostly powerful, are on the list of suspects.
Harris never ceases to amaze me how she is able to take the details of history, Regency era, in this case, and turn them into a cunning suspense. The main thread of this story is the tragic life and death of a talented woman set against social issues of the day- impressment of men into the Navy while their families are left destitute without them, the many minor crimes that were hanging offenses, the fate of wives who are married to abusive men, women with talent who must suppress this or let men take credit for their work, banking houses profiting from the war, royal house power struggles, suppression of the press' free speech, famine of hard winter, and more. I like how the social issues of the day are analyzed by Sebastian and Hero so that many aspects are revealed and thought through as they get to the heart of the matter.
Along with her gift to create fabulous historical settings and situations for her story, there is also her fantastic characters. I fell in love with Sebastian St. Cyr, Lord Devlin and his ongoing story from the first book. Sebastian is aristocracy, a former soldier, a child born of his mother's infidelity, a lost love in his past, and a new love in his present. Life's experiences give him a unique outlook and the skills to serve out justice for the dead. He's not infallible or untouchable. His errs have cost him deeply, but he grows and strengthens as the series progresses. He has learned so many secrets about his own past and another clue crops up, even now, when he least expects it about his mother's secret past.
I love how he sees his wife not only as the woman he loves and wants to protect, but Hero is is partner in all things. They solve the murders together, but, when not working a case, he does not interfere with Hero's important work among the poor classes. Hero investigates issues affecting the poor and writes up her finding calling for reform. Sebastian is not intimidated by her strong will or her choices. I love seeing them share intimacy and private moments as a couple and as parents to their young son. The author captures their eccentricity as individuals and a couple in that time, but also balances this just right so it never feels over the top or fake just to make them sensational. They are both very much aware of societies rules and just how far is too far and the consequences of crossing the wrong line.
Beyond the main pair of the story, the author doesn't chintz on several other recurring minor characters who make up Sebastian's circle with their own backgrounds and stories ongoing. Hero's powerful father, Lord Jarvis, who ruthlessly wields the power behind the throne and is up to his neck in intrigue, Sebastian's Irish surgeon friend Paul and the enigmatic French midwife Alexis who assist with the medical evidence side of the cases, Sebastian's father the Earl of Hendon, loyal Tom his street-wise servant, and, of late, I am very curious about Hero's mother's cousin Victoria and what she is up to as she insinuates herself into Jarvis' household and seems in on his schemes.
There was a tight mystery plot, lots of twists as Sebastian and Hero work to uncover the truth, and all that delicious family and palace intrigue. I anticipate each new Sebastian story and go into a bit of reading funk when I've finished the latest. Why Kill the Innocent is no exception. While this is a historical murder mystery, I think those who enjoy historical fiction that provides well-drawn characters, authentic historical elements, complex character and action-driven plots should give the series a go.
- Reviewed in the United States on April 4, 2018Another compelling, Regency detective story in the Sebastian St. Cyr series that kept me anxious to the very end. The uneasy alliance between Hero and Devlin as detectives has reached a point where they are not stumbling over each other so most of the focus in this book is devoted to suspense, which works well although I miss the introspection o the characters in the earlier books. Additionally, I hope that in future novels is for the character of Tom be given more attention.
- Reviewed in the United States on February 25, 2025Excellent book. Well written. Historically accurate, which added to the engagement of the book. Good mystery. Kept you guessing until the end.
- Reviewed in the United States on August 10, 2021An incomparable and mesmerizing character building was absolutely one of the many reasons this mystery series has become my obsession. Yes, the main characters Sebastian St Cyr and Hero, his viscountess certainly owned my heart. But my grief over the innocent murder victim, Jane Ambrose, went far beyond what I should have felt while reading a historical mystery. I lost my mind and shed more tears for her, for her inevitable tragic life. It was inevitable because of her being born a woman, in that culture of the Regency Era. It was what it was! Yeah, Right! Wrong‼️
Another historical comment, a heinous backdrop to the Regency Era, even when it had nothing to do with the mystery, still choked me up with fury, with helplessness, was the hanging of condemned criminals: like Amy, a new mother with a new born baby girl, her crime? trying to steal a ham; or three poachers, starving father and his two young boys!
The author once again, brilliantly wove a treachery web of Prince Regent's court, under the unscrupulous Lord Jarvis's manipulations, resulting in a gripping case for Lord Devlin to untangle and find justice for Jane. This time around, I got no satisfaction with the identity of the murderer. It was too sad, too pointless. It shouldn't have turned out that way. Had Hero not taken out the true villain who raped Jane during her final days of her life, I would've still been mad at how it all ended. So yeah ~ Hero remained MY as well as Sebastian's HERO 💘
The frozen Thames of 1814 made for a cool historical major event! Loved how it played an important and amazing part to the mystery!
This book celebrated Master Simon's first birthday and his precocious verbal brilliance in bonding with the black cat with green eyes and long fluffy tail ~ yup! the cat with a legendary name ➡️ "Mr. Darcy/Mm-ga-ga-gee (in Simon's own word)" ❣️
Top reviews from other countries
- big fan.Reviewed in the United Kingdom on October 29, 2023
5.0 out of 5 stars Good as ever
Mmmmm ....... I have read all of CSHarris books about Sebastian and Hero. This story I was eager to read as it is based in a particular interest of mine, the frost fair. This was described in such detail, I almost thought I was there !
Something bothered me about this book. None of the other books have. Brought and devoured in 2days mostly. Yep, it was the poor girls hanging Made me cry. Don't get me wrong, lots of books make me cry. And I know this is based on truth as discovered in the notes at the back of the book.
But I sometimes feel as though Hero or Sebastian could help the destitute people of London more. Surely Hero could have bribed officials with money for the poor girls release. If not them the guards. Now I know lots of people will say but that's what happened. But surely as a writer C S Harris could have bent the truth just a bit ....... a tiny little bit ......... But then I suppose, that's what kind of author she is, and why I love her books, because she is a bloody good one.
- MitchellReviewed in Canada on May 13, 2018
5.0 out of 5 stars One of C. S. Harris's keeps you on your toes in this one!
One of best reads to date. Kept me guessing until the last few chapters. Sebastian St. Cyr and his wife Hero are a great team and C. S. Harris just keeps getting better. Set in a period that's rarely used infliction much less suspense/thrillers, it grabs the history buf in me as well as the thriller buff.
The first book I picked up featuring Sebastian St. Cyr was one of those give it a go and see if it was any good, well, it was a treat to read and after so many books in the series, each is as good as the first. Can't wait for more adventures of Sebastian and Hero!
-
Andrea G.Reviewed in Germany on July 8, 2018
1.0 out of 5 stars Erschreckend antisemitisch
Ich habe bisher die Bücher der Reihe gerne gelesen, war aber schockiert von der offen antisemitischen Darstellung des Bankiers Rothschild in dieser Folge. Der Autorin ist es auf nur zwei Seiten "gelungen", ein vollständiges Zerrbild des ungepflegten, unkultivierten,unzivilisierten, heimatlosen und damit unpatriotischen, geld- und machtgierigen jüdischen Verbrechers mit der verräterisch abstoßenden Physiognomie zu zeichnen, dem man die Vergewaltigung und Ermordung des unschuldigen Opfers nur allzu gerne zutrauen möchte...
Einfach nur widerlich und für mich definitiv das letzte Buch dieser Autorin! Wenn es ginge, gäbe ich 0 Sterne.
- DarklldoReviewed in Australia on September 1, 2018
5.0 out of 5 stars C.S. Harris has done it again.
Accurate history wrapped up in well-grounded murder mysteries under the sharp notice of Sebastian St. Cyr, and his wife Hero!
Really, one can't ask for more if wishing to learn about the history of the ordinary people in 1814 London than to read this series.
- Regency BelleReviewed in the United Kingdom on April 4, 2018
4.0 out of 5 stars A Well Crafted Book- yet lacking something.
Once again, the author has given us a well crafted story, featuring characters we have come to know and love. It’s a good whodunnit, which gives readers another small glimpse into the St Cyr’s lives but failed to move on their story much farther than her previous books. It left this reader yearning for more.
Unfortunately, the story is very thin and covers a period of some two weeks in the lives of Sebastian and Hero. Although, enjoyable it lacks the depth and emotional range of previous books in this series. The various characters who make up the list of suspects are pretty one dimensional and not very likeable.
The redeeming quality of this book are the descriptions of the lives and abject poverty of the poor of Regency London. The author gives us glimpses, not only into the lives of the rich and well connected but into the lives of those struggling with debt, poverty and squalor.
The descriptions of public hangings, press ganging and the consequences of poverty on women are particularly moving. It also highlights how few rights women had in the early 19th century and the limited opportunities open to them and their children. It also exposes how little concern many of the wealthy classes showed to those they considered their inferiors.
My final comments are about the continuation of this series - how many more books does the author plan? I will remain loyal but there has to be some progression in the storyline, which will help resolve the big unanswered questions, which remain about Sebastian and Hero’s personal lives.